Convicts cannot be granted leave just for having conjugal relationship with spouse, rules HC

Bench says the benefit can be extended only for exceptional reasons such as a need to undergo infertility treatment

CHENNAI

In an authoritative pronouncement, a Full Bench (comprising three judges) of the Madras High Court has held that convicts cannot be granted ordinary leave just for having conjugal relationship with their spouse unless there were exceptional reasons such as a need to undergo infertility treatment.

Acting Chief Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari, Justice Pushpa Sathyanarayana and Justice P.D. Audikesavalu said: “A convict cannot enjoy all liberties available to a common person. Otherwise, there would no difference between a law-abiding citizen and a law-violating prisoner.”

They also wrote: “If grant of ordinary leave for having conjugal relationship is recognized to be a right under Article 21 (right to life and liberty) of the Constitution, the prayer of similar nature can be made by the accused or his/her spouse time and again to have conjugal relationship.”

Since Tamil Nadu Suspension of Service Rules of 1982 provide for grant of ordinary leave for “extraordinary reasons,” other than those listed out under the Rules, the judges said: “It can be granted to undergo infertility treatment, that too, for a convict having no child from the wedlock.”

They made it clear that if a convict already had a child or children from his/her wedlock, then he/she could not seek leave even for infertility treatment or any other similar reason. The Full Bench added that a same reason could not be sighted repeatedly to seek leave on multiple occasions.

The judgement was passed while answering a reference made by a Division Bench of the High Court on February 25, 2019. The Division Bench had referred the matter while dealing with a habeas corpus petition filed by the wife of a convict in the Coimbatore bomb blast case.

The Division Bench found that the petitioner’s husband had already been granted ordinary leave on January 11, 2018 for a period of two weeks to undergo infertility treatment. However, she had moved yet another application seeking leave once again for the same reason.

Not finding any provision in the 1982 Rules for grant of leave to a convict to have conjugal relationship with the spouse, the Division Bench referred the matter to the Full Bench.

Baby News

Related Posts

How an IVF mix-up went unnoticed for a decade, then changed two families’ lives forever

Comments Off on How an IVF mix-up went unnoticed for a decade, then changed two families’ lives forever

How NHS racism fears are risking fertility, with chlamydia blighting black Caribbean men and women

Comments Off on How NHS racism fears are risking fertility, with chlamydia blighting black Caribbean men and women

Rhian Sugden hits back at fans who think she’s pregnant after sharing positive Covid test

Comments Off on Rhian Sugden hits back at fans who think she’s pregnant after sharing positive Covid test

New campaign targets painful disease that affects 1 in 10 women

Comments Off on New campaign targets painful disease that affects 1 in 10 women

Anova Fertility, CCRM IVF, Chill, CREATE Fertility, Extend Fertility, HRC Fertility, IVF Australia, Kindbody, London Women’s Clinic, Manchester Fertility, Mayo Clinic, Melbourne IVF, Monash IVF, Pacific Fertility Center-Los Angeles (PFCLA), PIVET, Prelude Fertility, – The Host

Comments Off on Anova Fertility, CCRM IVF, Chill, CREATE Fertility, Extend Fertility, HRC Fertility, IVF Australia, Kindbody, London Women’s Clinic, Manchester Fertility, Mayo Clinic, Melbourne IVF, Monash IVF, Pacific Fertility Center-Los Angeles (PFCLA), PIVET, Prelude Fertility, – The Host

Meet Dylan Dreyer: Everything About the Famous Meteorologist

Comments Off on Meet Dylan Dreyer: Everything About the Famous Meteorologist

Couple Suing Doctor for Allegedly Inseminating Woman With Stranger’s Sperm

Comments Off on Couple Suing Doctor for Allegedly Inseminating Woman With Stranger’s Sperm

Moms who rage against the vaccine

Comments Off on Moms who rage against the vaccine

Motivator India bags integrated media duties for SpexMojo, Marketing & Advertising News, ET BrandEquity

Comments Off on Motivator India bags integrated media duties for SpexMojo, Marketing & Advertising News, ET BrandEquity

JPM22, Day 2: Tenet says it’s full steam ahead on ASCs, Progyny’s fertility services ‘resilient’ during pandemic and more

Comments Off on JPM22, Day 2: Tenet says it’s full steam ahead on ASCs, Progyny’s fertility services ‘resilient’ during pandemic and more

Ambient air pollution implicated in millions of underweight and premature births

Comments Off on Ambient air pollution implicated in millions of underweight and premature births

Pregnant Jeannie Mai Jenkins Recalls Starting IVF Shots the ‘Very Day of Our Wedding’

Comments Off on Pregnant Jeannie Mai Jenkins Recalls Starting IVF Shots the ‘Very Day of Our Wedding’

Create Account



Log In Your Account