Readers respond: An argument against ‘pregnant people’

I take issue with Therese Bottomly’s arguments related to “pregnant people” (“Letter from the Editor: Inclusive language illuminates changes in society,” Dec. 19). It doesn’t matter how some people “identify themselves.” If they are pregnant, they are women, that is just a biological fact. Biology is a science; it is not based on personal identification, but on scientific facts.

Bottomly’s argument that “1.2 million Americans identify as nonbinary” is meaningless. It doesn’t matter that this represents “more than the population of the city of Seattle or San Francisco.” It represents less than 0.4% of the U.S. population. And comparing the adoption of Ms. with the adoption of “pregnant people” (soon “pregnant men”?) is a slight exaggeration. One refers to stopping the immediate reference to the married status of women, the other one refers to a biological impossibility.

The fact that a government document refers to pregnant people is not relevant in today’s ultra-politicized atmosphere. I can almost guarantee that if an “ultraprogressive” person in the government used this expression, few others would have the courage to point out its absurdity; they would be afraid of being labeled with all kinds of unattractive adjectives.

Gabriel Farkas, Portland

Baby News

Related Posts

AP style guide adds phrase ‘pregnant people’ to the mockery of Twitter

Comments Off on AP style guide adds phrase ‘pregnant people’ to the mockery of Twitter

Kylie Jenner reveals she gained 60 POUNDS during second pregnancy but has already lost 40 pounds

Comments Off on Kylie Jenner reveals she gained 60 POUNDS during second pregnancy but has already lost 40 pounds

Vitamins are a waste of money for non-pregnant and healthy Americans, scientists say

Comments Off on Vitamins are a waste of money for non-pregnant and healthy Americans, scientists say

Driver in crash that killed pregnant Decatur woman gets 5-year prison sentence | Public Safety

Comments Off on Driver in crash that killed pregnant Decatur woman gets 5-year prison sentence | Public Safety

Pregnant Bharti Singh gives witty reply to question on her delivery date, jokes ‘we have a midwife in our midst?’ Watch

Comments Off on Pregnant Bharti Singh gives witty reply to question on her delivery date, jokes ‘we have a midwife in our midst?’ Watch

LETTERS: Who is going to care for pregnant mothers? | Letters

Comments Off on LETTERS: Who is going to care for pregnant mothers? | Letters

Chanel West Coast Is Pregnant, Expecting First Baby with Dom Fenison

Comments Off on Chanel West Coast Is Pregnant, Expecting First Baby with Dom Fenison

Suspect wanted for shooting pregnant woman, killing 2 unborn kids

Comments Off on Suspect wanted for shooting pregnant woman, killing 2 unborn kids

Pregnant Mollie King shows off her blossoming baby bump in array of stylish outfits

Comments Off on Pregnant Mollie King shows off her blossoming baby bump in array of stylish outfits

Whitney Port Pregnant With ‘Likely Another Unhealthy Pregnancy’

Comments Off on Whitney Port Pregnant With ‘Likely Another Unhealthy Pregnancy’

Carolyn Hax: Should favored child speak up on unfavored sister’s behalf?

Comments Off on Carolyn Hax: Should favored child speak up on unfavored sister’s behalf?

Katherine Ryan opens up about pregnancy loss in social media post

Comments Off on Katherine Ryan opens up about pregnancy loss in social media post

Create Account



Log In Your Account